I have been following the ‘Intelligent design’ debate raging in the US for the past couple of weeks and I have to say the conservative Christians come out looking stupid. I know it seems hard to believe…me criticizing Christian teachings, but come on, this stuff makes no sense.
Just recently the education board of Kansas has won a battle to introduce new science standards into classrooms across the state. For the most part these new ‘standards’ are about challenging the theory of evolution and seem to be a spring board to move intelligent design theory into the mainstream.
Among the most controversial changes was a redefinition of science itself, so that it would not be explicitly limited to natural explanations. *1
Where does this lead us?
The prime argument behind Intelligent design is that life is too complicated to have evolved or have started by accident, so there had to be some kind of guiding hand in the design process. Now of course the intelligent design flag wavers will admit that since the creation of all the animals, evolution has happened and accounts for the variation within species and so on. Nice of them to give some credit to Darwin, who is at least REAL.
However, Darwin’s ideas are criticized as faulty because they can’t explain absolutely everything, yet his theory of evolution has infiltrated all levels of science and is accepted as the most likely answer. In an effort to try and make intelligent design seem like a REAL science its proponents like to compare it with other ACTUAL sciences.
Intelligent Design is simply the science of design detection — how to recognize patterns arranged by an intelligent cause for a purpose. Design detection is used in a number of scientific fields, including anthropology, forensic sciences… cryptanalysis and the search for extraterrestrial intelligence (SETI) *2
The decision of the Kansas board of education can only be good for the world because it will lead to other states following suit. In the long term this will retard the intellectual development of the USA and as it descends back into the mire of Christian Science it will be unable to invade countries that piss them off or have oil. Or maybe it won’t be good. The crusades spring to mind. But I suppose by the time the ‘New Crusades’ start they will be a perfect imitation of the originals, as the US will have devolved (no pun intended) back to swords, horses and sailing ships through the help of ignorance combined with conviction.
*1 http://www.nytimes.com/2005/11/09/national/09kansas.html
*2 http://www.intelligentdesignnetwork.org/